The Fallacy of Compostability: What Consumers Need to Know

See “Compostable” on a Package? Read This First

Feels like a win for the planet. But not all compostable products are created equal. The difference between home compostable and industrial compostable matters more than most people realize.

The Reality of Compostability

A compostable product is designed to break down into nutrient-rich soil. But where it composts makes all the difference.

Home compostability is a much higher standard than industrial compostability because it works in natural backyard settings—not just specialized commercial ones.

The Impact

  • Consumer Confusion: Many assume all compostable products break down at home, leading to improper disposal and landfill waste.
  • Environmental Misdirection: Industrially compostable products that don’t reach a proper facility act like plastic and cause pollution.
  • Waste Management Issues: Cities struggle to manage packaging requiring industrial composting but ending up in the trash.

What You Can Do

  • Check for trusted certifications:
    • BPI Compostable—ensures industrial compostability
    • Seedling Logo—European industrial compost standard
    • DIN CERTCO or TÜV Austria OK Compost Home—reliable home compost certification
  • Read the fine print: Labels should indicate if industrial facilities are required
  • Prefer natural fiber-based materials: Bagasse, bamboo, palm leaves, or molded fiber
  • Avoid bioplastics like PLA or PHA unless explicitly certified for home composting
  • Test it yourself: Compost small pieces at home—if it’s still there after 6–12 months, it’s not truly home compostable
  • Support transparent brands: Choose companies that explain their sustainability claims clearly

Industrial Compostability: A Limited Solution

Products labeled “industrially compostable” only break down in controlled facilities with:

  • High heat: 131°F–170°F (55°C–77°C)
  • Moisture and airflow management: Required to optimize decomposition

Without these conditions, they persist like traditional plastics.

The Impact

  • Limited access: Most cities lack proper industrial composting facilities
  • Curbside confusion: Not all programs accept compostable packaging
  • Landfill contamination: Compostables in landfills don’t break down properly and contribute to methane emissions

What You Can Do

  • Check if your region has access to industrial composting
  • Support better municipal programs for compostables
  • Choose home compostable items whenever possible

Home Compostability: The Real Deal

Home compostable products break down in natural conditions—no fancy equipment needed.

  • Works at lower temperatures: 50°F–113°F (10°C–45°C)
  • Breaks down in backyard bins: No special systems required
  • Typical timeframe: Decomposes fully within 12 months

The Impact

  • True sustainability: Breaks down anywhere, naturally
  • Lower emissions: No transport needed to industrial sites
  • Better awareness: Educates consumers about proper disposal and circular practices

What You Can Do</

Download our Catalog


Get A Quote